Monday, August 24, 2009
UPDATED: Buffalo firefighters killed this morning are Lt. Charles "Chip" McCarthy & FF Jonathan Croom. Fireground audio of mayday.
Click here and then scroll down for the latest fire and EMS news from STATter911.com
Two clips of raw video from this morning's fire.
Listen to dispatch and fireground audio: Part 1, Part 2, Part 3 (mayday), Part 4. (For the radio traffic of the entire day click here and go to the bottom of the page and choose the date & time under "feed archives".)
Firefighters remove bodies of their colleagues from the building
Later firefighting and recovery efforts
List of previous LODDs in Buffalo
UPDATED at 4:15 PM
At a noon press conference, Buffalo Fire Commissioner Michael Lombardo said there was a 911 report of someone who may be trapped inside 1815 Genesee just before 4:00 this morning. Lt. Charles "Chip" McCarthy of Rescue Company 1 and Firefighter Jonathan Croom of Ladder Company 7, both on the first alarm, went into the building to search for the possible victim. A mayday was called a little more than a half-hour into the indicent. The bodies of the two firefighters were found together in the basement of the structure after the first floor collapsed.
Lt. McCarthy was 45-years-old and a 22-year veteran. Firefighter Croom was 34-years-old and had 10-years on the department.
Buffalo Fire Department pictures of Lt. Charles "Chip" McCarthy & Firefighter Jonathan Croom via The Buffalo News.The fire occurred in the 1815 Genesee Street at the Super Speedy Deli. It was reported at 3:49 AM.
The fireground audio clearly has dispatchers providing the report of people trapped. Engine 31 reported smoke showing as the crew left its quarters and confirmed the report of people trapped as they arrived on the scene. Engine 31 also reports confirmation of a basement fire and command tells firefighters to use caution.
An additional two engines and a ladder were requested.
Later there is a report of a person possibly trapped in the basement. Command tells Rescue 1 Portable there was what sounded like someone pounding on the door in the basement.
At about 4:09 AM, Command gave the following report:
Twenty minutes into 1815 Genesee Street. Two-story ordinary. We are now operating three, inch and three quarter lines. We are doing an agressive interior search. We still have a report of civilians trapped. We believe they may be in the basement. We are going to hold everybody we have including the two and one.
Command soon asks for the balance of the second alarm. There are reports of difficulty getting into a basement door and deteriorating conditions on the first floor.
Here is the report from Command at the thirty-minute mark:
Thirty minutes into 1815 Genesee Street. Still continuing to operate all hands. We will continue to hold the second alarm.
The mayday occurs a short time later after a discussion with Ladder 14 about progress on the basement door. As a number of units try to determine more about the mayday, Rescue 1 reports, "I believe I hear screaming in the front of the basement number one side."
Excerpts from The Buffalo News report by Gene Warner, Brian Meyer and Pete Simon:
Reports from the scene indicated the two firefighters may have fallen through the first floor while searching for a civilian victim. Earlier reports that someone was trapped inside were not confirmed, and some officials said they doubted a third person had been trapped."It's a very tragic day for the city of Buffalo," Mayor Byron W. Brown said during a noon news conference. "Our hearts are broken right now."
McCarthy leaves behind his wife, three children and a 6-month-old grandchild. Croom leaves behind a 9-month-old child and a fiancee. A few years ago, Croom himself lost a young child.
Fire Commissioner Michael Lombardo fought back tears during the news conference, saying he knew both men and described them as "terrific firefighters" who both received honors for their work in the past.
The two firefighters' deaths represent the first multiple loss of life in the Buffalo Fire Department since five firefighters and two civilians were killed in a propane explosion on North Division Street in December 1983.

The building that burned this morning at 1815 Genesee Street. Click the image for the Google Maps Street View.Ehmed Mallahi said based on what he observed shortly after the fire broke out, he thinks the building was unoccupied at the time.
"It's a shame they risked lives, because I don't think there was anyone in there at the time," Mallahi said. However, another neighbor who lived upstairs from the deli, Hamood Abdulla, said he heard what appeared to a burglar alarm. He went outside, didn't see anything, called the owner and later smelled smoke. That's when he called 911.
Meanwhile, a passerby came by and yelled, "Does anybody need help?" according to Abdulla.
"Somebody from inside said, "Help me,'" he added. "He kept saying, "Help me.'"
While those reports appeared to conflict, it's possible both accounts are accurate, that a civilian — possibly a burglar — was inside the building but fled before firefighters arrived at the scene.
Earlier report with video of fire.
Buffalo Fire Commissioner Michael Lombardo confirms firefighters are missing.
Also to the brothers and sisters of the Buffalo Fire Dept.
Sgt. J.Kerr
Swoope Vol. Fire Co.
God Bless All Brothers of Buffalo
Capt. A. Coe
Valley View FPD
E-24
RS-2
DCFD
During accountability ladder 7 stated all were ok. Did FF Croom fall later during FAST operations?
Floyd Aldridge Jr
DCFD (RETIRED)
The Members of
Engine Company No. 4
District of Columbia F.D.
I'll be praying for the survivors, the family and the community.
As I listened to the radio traffic for this alarm, I was impressed with the leadership and the system in place. The firefighters were brave and aggressive with the fire attack. The FAST-Team/RIT was assigned and ready. The IC was not afraid to delegate responsibility as other Chiefs became available. He called for additional companies and had them immediately available in staging. The Dispatchers were giving the IC time-hacks and he was continually monitoring the fire conditions.
With all the good things the IC and the system was accomplishing, we (the Fire Service) still have two dead firefighters... WHY.???
Because our Pride so often will not allow us to admit defeat...
"Defeat" as in TIME'S UP.!!!
We cannot stop this GROWING FIRE with aggressive offensive tactics.
TIME'S UP.. no more residents can be saved.
TIME'S UP .. get all the firefighters out while they an still get out.
TIME'S UP .. go defensive....
Heavy streams from the outside and fill the basement with HI-X Foam.
We need to STOP trading firefighters for JUNK.!!!
“For 200 years we’ve been providing a service at the expense of those providing the service.” Alan Brunacini, Fire Chief (ret) PFD
Listening to more radio traffic than Dave has posted here:
http://www.radioreference.com/apps/audio/?feedId=745
(go to the audio archives at the bottom)
Ladder 7 gives another all clear on the accountablity between 0442 and 0457 (times according to the archive names).
During this time period there were reports of FF's on the first floor partially fallng through the floor. Command pulled everyone out. Ladder 7 reported all clear after this.
Command becomes aware that FF Croom may be missing between 0457 and 512 and attempts to raise him.
It appears that FF Croom comes up on the radio between 0512 and 0527. A FF says "I'm here. I'm right here. I'm accounted for." Not in any apparent distress.
They dispatch tries to raise him again about 10 minutes later and there is no response.
Wherever Flames may rage,
Give me the strength to save some life
Whatever Be its age.
Help me embrace a little child
Before it is too late
Or save an older person from
The horror of that fate
Enable me to be alert,
and oh Lord, guide my every move,
for life is so precious,
please don't let us loose.
I want to fill my calling and
To give the best in me
To guard my every neighbor
And protect their property
And if according to thy will,
That I must give my life,
Then with thy protecting hand my Lord,
I pray thee, protect my children and my wife.
Amen
Why dont we let these brothers GRIEVE first before you start pointing fingers and laying blame.
I guess you are so all knowing that you dont have to wait for the after incident report. I guess you are so all knowing that you didnt have to be there to know exactly what these brothers were faced with.
Do us all a favor and keep your mouth shut and crawl in to a hall and wait for your last alarm!
Sid
I think that was an Anonymous poster quoting Brunacini not Brunacini himself. So before you mouth off about Alan and drag him into this, please take the time to read the posts more carefully.
Yes, I agree that 43 and the whole department for that matter was very professional, competent, and aggressive. Sorry the results were so tragic.
Let us grieve for these brave men, their brothers of the BFD, and their families, and lay them to rest before all the safety gurus step out from the rocks they hide under and start telling everyone how to fight fires from the outside.
God Speed Lt. McCarthy and FF Croom, may you now watch over and protect all those that you love.
Links to this post:
<< Home
Subscribe to Posts [Atom]

